From: "Mit Windows Internet Explorer 8 gespeichert" Subject: Opening Remarks on the Occasion of Manfred Bonitz's 70th Anniversary Date: Thu, 19 Jan 2012 14:00:17 +0100 MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/html; charset="utf-8" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Location: http://garfield.library.upenn.edu/papers/bonitzsymposium3162001.html X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V6.0.6001.18483 =EF=BB=BF Opening Remarks on the Occasion of Manfred Bonitz's = 70th Anniversary
Opening Remarks on the = Occasion=20 of
Manfred = Bonitz=EF=BF=BDs=20 70th Anniversary=20

Presented by
Eugene Garfield
Chairman=20 Emeritus, ISI=C3=A2
Publisher,=20 The Scientist=C3=A2 =
3501 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA=20 19104
Tel. 215-243-2205
Fax 215-387-1266
E-mail: garfield@codex.cis.upenn.edu= =20
Website: http://www.eugenegarfield.org/=20

Presented at the
Patterns in Scientific Communication =EF=BF=BD =
The Matthew Effect in Science and beyond =
Colloquium in Honour of the 70th Birthday of Dr. = Manfred=20 Bonitz
Berlin =
March 16, 2001


To = properly=20 review the work of a highly productive scientist like Manfred Bonitz = would=20 require a doctoral dissertation. If only I could afford the luxury of = devoting=20 the time and energy to such an endeavor. These introductory remarks = can only=20 touch very lightly on his career. And fortunately others more = qualified than I=20 will soon address you in greater detail about his=20 accomplishments.=20

I do not = recall the exact=20 circumstances and events which led Manfred to enter the field of = information=20 science about 1970. Until that time he had a highly productive career = as a=20 nuclear physicist. In the United States during the 1950=EF=BF=BDs and = 1960=EF=BF=BDs many=20 nuclear physicists entered the fields of information science and = science=20 policy. Among the many who migrated from physics to information = science were=20 Don Swanson, Derek Price, Larry Halperin, William Goffman, among = others. Their=20 mathematical skills and training helped illuminate the laws of = information=20 science and scientometrics. They stressed the need to maintain a high = level of=20 discipline necessary to produce high quality science-based information = and=20 bibliometric research. In the East a similar migration from physical = science=20 to information science often occurred and calls to mind such = outstanding=20 scholars as Avril Avramescu, Vassily Nalimov, and Gennadi Dubrov, and = our=20 friends at VINITI A.I. Mikhailov, R. Gilyarevski, and A.=20 Chernyi.=20

Thanks to = Manfred Bonitz,=20 my work became much better known amongst East and West German readers = due=20 especially to the series of book reviews of my Essays of an = Information=20 Science volumes which he published over a seventeen-year period. = Further,=20 he was an important constructive critic of ISI products, beginning = with a=20 review of the ISI Journal Citation Reports=C2=AE in=20 1983.=20

In his work, = Manfred has=20 expressed the belief that only truth and scientific relevance should = be the=20 criteria for a scientific work to be accepted, that science is = universal, and=20 the world-wide scientific community =EF=BF=BD despite all "social = perturbations" -- is=20 a kind of ideal society: democratic, objective, just. If you are = active in=20 science then you have to compare yourself with the rest of the world. = It took=20 great courage for him to write about GDR-Science in the mirror of=20 international journals, an article which I imagine caused him some = trouble at=20 the time. He expressed the view that the Science Citation=20 Index=C2=AE is an unique mirror of the world-society of = science,=20 that it is interdisciplinary and it is =EF=BF=BD at least =EF=BF=BD = created by scientists=20 themselves. This aspect of the SCI,=C2=AE I guess, = attracted him=20 from the beginning. It made him one of the decisive defenders (even = though not=20 without criticism) of the SCI.=20

In this = respect, I cannot=20 fail to mention another unusual scientist from Vladivostok, Victor = Vaskovsky=20 who also saw in the SCI these qualities and, like Manfred, = became my=20 long-time personal friend and the first Russian member of the = editorial board=20 of the SCI.=20

Manfred=EF=BF=BDs work on "human=20 behavior in scientific communication" was published both in German and = English. And he has made numerous contributions, both as an author and = editor,=20 to the journal Scientometrics over the last decade. Manfred has = always=20 been extremely generous in publishing tributes to information pioneers = as in=20 the case of Nalimov, Price, and others. His investigations of the work = of=20 Wilhelm Ostwald is also noteworthy.=20

In the early = 90s, Manfred=20 began his work on co-structure cluster maps, leading in more recent = times to=20 the magnum opus the Atlas of the Matthew Core Journals. = This=20 was created with the help of his long-time collaborator Andrea=20 Scharnhorst. This work followed from his encounter with Robert = Merton=EF=BF=BDs 1968=20 classic paper on the "Matthew Effect" and its follow on in = 1988. These=20 papers ultimately brought him in direct in person contact with = Professor=20 Merton. I can personally attest that Merton has marveled at the way in = which=20 Manfred and his colleagues have developed this theme. As Dr. Merton = also=20 points out "Bonitz inaugurated an altogether new phase in the = systematic=20 investigation of the phenomena caught up in the concept of the Matthew = Effect." The Atlas is a completely unexpected outcome of = Merton=EF=BF=BDs=20 original sociological observation of individual behavior which has now = been=20 given a global perspective. As Merton observed: "By ingenious and = original use=20 of the Science Citation Index, you have gone on to discover the = Matthew=20 Effect for countries."=20

So I will = close this short=20 introduction with a toast to Manfred on his 70th birthday = which I=20 am sure we will repeat many times during our social encounters here. I = also=20 want to thank you all for coming, and also wish to thank Andrea = Scharnhorst,=20 Professor Walther Umst=C3=A4tter, and Dr. Heinrich Parthey for = inviting me to begin=20 this happy occasion.